The Lid Test

The Best Modular Motorcycle Helmets

Flip-up touring helmets compared on shell material, sun visor and comms integration — the convenience of an open-face with the coverage of a full-face.

By Stephen V.Last verified How we compare

A modular—or flip-up—helmet lets you lift the chin bar and face shield as one piece, so you can talk, drink, or take a breather at a gas stop without pulling the whole helmet off. That single feature makes modulars the touring and commuting favorite: glasses-wearers love them, and so does anyone who stops often. The trade-off is a little extra weight and usually a little more wind noise than a full-face, because the flip mechanism is one more thing air can find.

We compared these on the same terms as any helmet—certification, weight, shell material, and a live price—plus the two things that matter most on a modular: whether it has a drop-down sun visor and how cleanly it integrates comms. The Shoei Neotec 3 is the class benchmark and the one everything else is measured against; the Schuberth C5 is the only helmet here built to the same brief, and the two of them are worth comparing directly before you spend flagship money. Both cost multiples of the value picks ranked below them. Read the table for the verdict, then dive into any write-up.

How this is funded: we earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which helmet we recommend, and we’ll tell you plainly when a cheaper or lighter one is the better buy. Full disclosure.

Quick picks

Ranked on our spec score — certification, weight, features and value. Select a row to jump to the full write-up. We have not tested these helmets; here is exactly how we compare them instead.

#HelmetBest forOur scorePrice
1
Shoei Neotec 3

Shoei Neotec 3

The touring modular the class is measured against. DOT and ECE 22.06, an AIM composite shell, a bigger QSV-2 sun visor and a Defogger-equipped shield — plus the cleanest integration for Shoei's own comms system. It is expensive and worth understanding why.

Best overall9.2
$949.99 · View on Amazon

Price as of September 19, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

2
Schuberth C5

Schuberth C5

The touring modular that treats wind noise and comms as engineering problems rather than marketing. Schuberth's own US data sheet claims P/J DOT homologation — approved to ride with the chin bar up or down — a Pinlock 120 already fitted, three comms antennas laid into the shell, and 85 dB(A) at 62 mph on a naked bike. It is also the heaviest premium modular we list, and it is flagship money.

Best for long-distance touring8.9
$799.00 · View on Amazon

Price as of September 19, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

3
HJC RPHA 91

HJC RPHA 91

HJC's composite touring modular splits the difference: a P.I.M. EVO carbon-blend shell and a drop-down sun visor at a mid price, ready for HJC's own SMART Bluetooth. Not as quiet as a Schuberth, a lot cheaper than one.

Best value composite8.5
$559.99 · View on Amazon

Price as of September 19, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

4

Sena Outrush R

The shortcut to a helmet-and-comms setup: the Outrush R builds Bluetooth speakers, a mic and a 4-way intercom into the shell, so there is no external unit to buy, clamp on or charge separately. DOT-certified, with a sun visor, at a single sensible price.

Best built-in comms8.1
5
Scorpion EXO-GT930 Transformer

Scorpion EXO-GT930 Transformer

The trick here is a genuinely removable chin bar — the GT930 runs as a full-face or, with the bar off, a proper open-face, which few modulars actually allow. Add a sun visor and a sub-$300 price and it's the value convertible.

Best convertible7.9
$279.95 · View on Amazon

Price as of September 19, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

The picks in full

#1Best overallOur score9.2

Shoei Neotec 3

The touring modular the class is measured against. DOT and ECE 22.06, an AIM composite shell, a bigger QSV-2 sun visor and a Defogger-equipped shield — plus the cleanest integration for Shoei's own comms system. It is expensive and worth understanding why.

Strengths

  • DOT and ECE 22.06 in a composite AIM shell — not the polycarbonate most modulars use
  • QSV-2 internal sun visor is larger than the old QSV-1, and the CNS-3C shield is Pinlock-ready with a defogger
  • Purpose-built channel for the SRL3/COMLINK comms unit — no bulky external clamp

Trade-offs

  • The most expensive modular we cover — flagship money for a flip-up
  • Comms unit is a separate, Shoei-specific purchase
CertificationsDOT, ECE 22.06
Weight1700 g
ShellAIM composite
Head shapeIntermediate oval
SizesXS-2XL
Internal sun visorYes
Pinlock-readyYes

Notable. QSV-2 sun visor; CNS-3C Pinlock shield with defogger; SRL3/COMLINK-ready

Specs read from the manufacturer / retailer listing, on July 19, 2026. “Not published” means the maker does not state that figure.

#2Best for long-distance touringOur score8.9

Schuberth C5

The touring modular that treats wind noise and comms as engineering problems rather than marketing. Schuberth's own US data sheet claims P/J DOT homologation — approved to ride with the chin bar up or down — a Pinlock 120 already fitted, three comms antennas laid into the shell, and 85 dB(A) at 62 mph on a naked bike. It is also the heaviest premium modular we list, and it is flagship money.

Strengths

  • Schuberth publishes P/J DOT FMVSS 218 homologation — the helmet is approved to ride with the chin bar open as well as closed, where most modulars are approved closed only
  • Pinlock 120 comes preinstalled on a distortion-free class 1 visor, and the V-lock drop-down sun visor is standard
  • Speakers plus separate Mesh, FM radio and Bluetooth antennas are built into the shell for the SC2 or SC EDGE, so nothing clamps to the outside
  • Two shell sizes cover eight head sizes from 51 to 65 cm — genuinely small and genuinely large heads are both catered for
  • A.R.O.S. anti-roll-off chin strap geometry, and an exchangeable filter in the double chin intake

Trade-offs

  • Heavy: Schuberth's own figures run 1,780-1,910 g depending on size, roughly 90-210 g more than a Shoei Neotec 3
  • The US data sheet claims DOT only — no ECE 22.06 and no Snell for the version sold here
  • Flagship money, and the SC2 comms unit is a separate purchase on top of it
  • The 85 dB(A) figure is Schuberth's own wind-tunnel claim on a naked bike; no independent body verifies helmet noise, so treat it as a design intent rather than a measurement you can compare across brands
CertificationsDOT
Weight1790 g
ShellDFP (Direct Fiber Processing) fiberglass reinforced with basalt
Head shapeIntermediate oval
SizesXXS-3XL (51-65 cm)
Internal sun visorYes
Pinlock-readyYes

Notable. P/J DOT homologation; Pinlock 120 preinstalled; Mesh, FM and Bluetooth antennas built into the shell for the SC2 / SC EDGE; A.R.O.S. anti-roll-off

Specs read from the manufacturer / retailer listing, on August 30, 2026. “Not published” means the maker does not state that figure.

#3Best value compositeOur score8.5

HJC RPHA 91

HJC's composite touring modular splits the difference: a P.I.M. EVO carbon-blend shell and a drop-down sun visor at a mid price, ready for HJC's own SMART Bluetooth. Not as quiet as a Schuberth, a lot cheaper than one.

Strengths

  • P.I.M. EVO shell blends carbon, glass and linen fibers — lighter than a polycarbonate modular
  • Drop-down sun visor and a Pinlock-ready face shield included
  • Purpose-made for the SMART HJC 21B/50B Bluetooth units

Trade-offs

  • The page we verified listed DOT only (no ECE/Snell stated)
  • Comms is HJC-specific; heavier than the flagship composites
CertificationsDOT
Weight1742 g
ShellP.I.M. EVO (carbon, carbon-glass and linen fiber)
Head shapeIntermediate oval
SizesXS-2XL
Internal sun visorYes
Pinlock-readyYes

Notable. Drop-down sun visor; Pinlock-ready shield; SMART HJC Bluetooth-ready

Specs read from the manufacturer / retailer listing, on July 19, 2026. “Not published” means the maker does not state that figure.

#4Best built-in commsOur score8.1

Sena Outrush R

The shortcut to a helmet-and-comms setup: the Outrush R builds Bluetooth speakers, a mic and a 4-way intercom into the shell, so there is no external unit to buy, clamp on or charge separately. DOT-certified, with a sun visor, at a single sensible price.

Strengths

  • Bluetooth 5.1 comms are built in — speakers, mic and a 4-way ~900 m intercom, up to 18 hours talk
  • One purchase covers helmet plus comms; nothing to clamp to the side
  • Includes a drop-down sun visor

Trade-offs

  • Polycarbonate shell; DOT listed but no ECE/Snell on the pages we verified
  • Built-in comms means you can't swap to a Cardo mesh system later
CertificationsDOT
Weight1730 g
ShellPolycarbonate ABS with multi-density EPS
Head shapeIntermediate oval
SizesS-2XL
Internal sun visorYes
Pinlock-readyNo

Notable. Integrated Bluetooth 5.1 comms (4-way intercom, ~900 m, 18 h talk); sun visor

Specs read from the manufacturer / retailer listing, on July 19, 2026. “Not published” means the maker does not state that figure.

#5Best convertibleOur score7.9

Scorpion EXO-GT930 Transformer

The trick here is a genuinely removable chin bar — the GT930 runs as a full-face or, with the bar off, a proper open-face, which few modulars actually allow. Add a sun visor and a sub-$300 price and it's the value convertible.

Strengths

  • Removable chin bar converts between full-face and open-face configurations
  • SpeedView drop-down internal sun visor and EXO-COM Bluetooth-ready pockets
  • DOT and ECE 22.05 certified at a budget price; includes a detachable peak

Trade-offs

  • Certified to the older ECE 22.05, not 22.06
  • Polycarbonate shell is heavy (~1,814 g) — one of the weightier lids here
CertificationsDOT, ECE 22.05
Weight1814 g
ShellAdvanced polycarbonate
Head shapeIntermediate oval
SizesXS-3XL
Internal sun visorYes
Pinlock-readyNo

Notable. Removable chin bar (full-face to open-face); SpeedView sun visor; EXO-COM-ready

Specs read from the manufacturer / retailer listing, on July 19, 2026. “Not published” means the maker does not state that figure.

How to choose a modular helmet

Shell material is the big divider.Most modulars use polycarbonate, which is heavier; the premium ones (the Neotec 3, the HJC RPHA 91) use a composite shell that shaves real weight off a helmet type that’s already heavier than a full-face. On a touring day, that weight difference is what your neck feels at hour six.

Decide how you want comms. There are two routes. A helmet with built-inBluetooth like the Sena Outrush R means one purchase and nothing to clamp on—but you can’t swap comms brands later. A comms-readyhelmet (the Neotec 3 with Shoei’s SRL3, the RPHA 91 with HJC’s SMART unit) has a purpose-built channel for that brand’s module, which is cleaner than a universal clamp-on but ties you to that ecosystem. Schuberthtakes that route furthest — the speakers and the Mesh, FM and Bluetooth antennas are laid into the C5’s shell at the factory, so only the unit itself is a purchase — and our Schuberth C5 review covers what that unit costs and why the helmet does nothing on comms until you buy one. If you want total freedom, buy any modular and add a standalone intercom.

A sun visor is nearly universal here—use it.Almost every modular includes a drop-down internal sun visor, which is one of the best convenience features in motorcycling. The Scorpion EXO-GT930 goes further with a genuinely removable chin bar, so it runs as a full-face or a true open-face—two helmets in one for the money.

Published weight and noise, side by side

Weight and wind noise are the two complaints riders have about modulars, so here is every figure the five makers actually publish. The weight column is each maker’s or retailer’s own number and the reference size is often unstated, so treat gaps under about 100 g as noise rather than signal. The noise column is the interesting one: four of these five companies publish nothing at all.

HelmetPublished weightShellPublished noise figure
Shoei Neotec 31,700 g (Shoei, size not stated)AIM compositeNone published
Schuberth C51,780–1,910 g by size (Schuberth)DFP fiberglass with basalt85 dB(A) at 62 mph, maker’s own wind tunnel
HJC RPHA 91~1,742 g (3.84 lb, RevZilla)P.I.M. EVO compositeNone published
Sena Outrush R1,730 g in size M (Sena)Polycarbonate ABSNone published
Scorpion EXO-GT930~1,814 g (4.0 lb, RevZilla)Advanced polycarbonateNone published

That single Schuberth figure is worth reading carefully rather than trusting. It is the maker’s own wind-tunnel measurement, taken on a naked bike, and there is no independent body that verifies helmet noise and no standard protocol the others run — so it cannot be compared against four blanks. It tells you Schuberth treats aeroacoustics as an engineering target, and nothing more than that. Our quietest helmets ranking explains how we judge quiet without a decibel meter, and how to reduce wind noise makes the point that outranks every helmet on this page: earplugs cut more noise than the difference between any two of these.

Frequently asked questions

Are modular helmets as safe as full-face helmets?

A modular from a reputable maker that carries current certification (DOT plus ECE 22.06, like the Neotec 3) is a genuinely protective helmet. That said, the flip-up chin bar is a moving joint, so a full-face of equal quality is structurally simpler and typically a bit lighter and quieter. Buy a modular for the convenience it gives you, not despite a safety penalty — just make sure it's certified, and always ride with the chin bar latched down.

Can you ride with the chin bar up?

Only at low speed, if at all — an open chin bar wrecks the aerodynamics and offers no face protection. Some modulars are certified in both the closed and open positions (a 'P/J' rating) and some are not. The flip is designed for stops, not for cruising. Always latch the chin bar closed before you get up to road speed.

Why are modular helmets more expensive?

The flip-up mechanism, the extra seals, and usually a drop-down sun visor all add cost and complexity over a full-face. That's why the value picks in this list matter: the HJC RPHA 91 gets you a composite shell and a sun visor at a mid price, and the Scorpion EXO-GT930 adds a removable chin bar for under $300.

Do modular helmets have more wind noise?

Generally a little, yes — the flip mechanism creates more paths for air than a one-piece full-face shell. Premium modulars like the Neotec 3 engineer around this with tight seals and a padded neck roll, but if absolute quiet is your priority, a full-face usually edges it. See our quietest-helmets roundup for the design features that reduce noise.

Sources

Keep reading